Support for Pakistani Artists - A righteous approach or a case of opportunism


A section of Bollywood has come out in open support of the Pakistani Artists after the unfortunate Uri attacks, in which, 19 of our soldiers embraced martyrdom.  Popular Filmmaker Karan Johar  claimed that Artists are vulnerable soft targets and they should be left alone! Other big names like Salman Khan and Shyam Benegal have also spoken in favour of the Pakistani actors. Now let us see as to how justified is their support.  

Picture Credit: Times of India
First and foremost, as a part of a professional industry, the members of our film fraternity need to know that every market provides some opportunities, and at the same time, every market has some threats.  The liberalization of Indian economy has led to an unprecedented rise in the spending power of the Indians, and Bollywood has been gleefully cashing on this opportunity. The once elusive magic figure of 100 crores has become a norm these days. Therefore, the same Bollywood cannot cry foul on being confronted with the threats (that include the diplomatic and military confrontation with Pakistan) of the Indian market. The film fraternity can do well to learn a lesson or two from our sports fraternity in Cricket, Badminton and Kabaddi, who like them are also in the field of entertainment but have decided to boycott Pakistan in solidarity with our armed forces and the mood of the nation.

Some people also come up with arguments such as Artists are border-less, Art should not be mixed with Politics etc.However, all these arguments hold little or no merit. To begin with, Artists are not border-less. They don't perform in a vacuum or a flag-less land rather they perform for a specific audience within a specific boundary, and hence they have to be accountable towards their audience, and also the land in which they perform for earning their livelihood. Secondly, god forbids but if the next 26/11 was to happen, and the house of some of the Bollywood personalities was to be attacked (particularly those who are supporting the Pakistanis now), then it is the members of our  Armed forces, who would put their lives at risk for these so called 'border-less' people. I shudder to think of a day when our soldiers start behaving like Bollywood personalities and start saying - "Don't mix our lives with politics".

If a section of Bollywood  expects an average Indian to use one of its hands for placing a wreath on the bodies of our soldiers, and the other for clapping in adulation of the Pakistani Artists, then it is perhaps asking for too much. While sympathising with Fawad Khan, Mahira Khan et al, Bollywood also needs to be mindful of the sentiments  of the families of the martyrs, who have sacrificed their lives so that people from the film fraternity could live a peaceful and a comfortable life in Mumbai without the fear of any external aggression.

For long it has been believed that rogue elements like Dawood Ibrahim have a strong influence over Bollywood, and  looking at the pro Pakistani voices at a time when there is  lot of resentment against Pakistan, and  also when India  is trying to isolate Pakistan from all the corners, one cannot help but wonder if ISI has indeed managed to penetrate in our film industry!